Ay Caramba! Menu
71 items in 12 sections · $3.74 – $44.99 · Mexican Restaurant in Prunedale, CA
Ay Caramba!’s menu lists 71 dishes and drinks, grouped into Independencia Day, Molletes, Cortes (Steaks), Main Dishes, Desserts, and Omelette and more. Prices range from $3.74 to $44.99, and a typical item costs about $12.50. Popular choices include PLATO DE CARNITAS, BEENS & CHEESE, Arrachera Nortena, Torta Milanesa, and Pastries.
Independencia Day 6
- PLATO DE CARNITAS$23.44
- POZOLE ROJO$18.74
- QUESABIRRIAS$25.94
- TOSTADAS DE TINGA$18.74
- TAMALES$18.74
- PAMBAZOS$10.00
Molletes 2
- BEENS & CHEESE$12.50
- CHORIZO$12.50
Cortes (Steaks) 2
- Arrachera Nortena$44.99
- Skirt Steak 12oz$43.74
Main Dishes 14
- Torta Milanesa$19.69
- Burrito$19.69
- Burrito Breakfast$20.94
- Baja Tacos$23.74
- Ensalada De Pollo A La Plancha$22.49
- Molcajete$37.50
- Chile Relleno$23.44
- Burger$22.50
- Fajitas$31.25
- Enchiladas$22.50
- RIBEYE ROLITOS$22.49
- Burrito Vegetarian$20.94
- Burrito Bean&Cheese$13.74
- Taco Plate$22.19
Desserts 8
- Pastries$8.75
- Churros$10.00
- Roulette$7.50
- Fresas Con Crema$10.00
- Cheesecake$10.00
- Flan De La Casa$10.00
- Sorbett$6.25
- Crepa$10.00
Omelette 2
- BACOON$12.50
- HAM & CHEESE$12.50
Extras 15
- 32 Oz Rice$11.24
- 25oz Salsa$11.24
- Extra Chicken$6.24
- Beans 8oz$6.24
- Side Rice$3.74
- 8oz Salsa$6.24
- Side Fries$7.49
- Extra Tortillas$3.74
- Side Beans$3.74
- Rice 8oz$6.24
- 32oz Beans$11.24
- Xtra Shrimp$7.49
- Extra Avocado$4.99
- Side Guacamole$6.24
- Extra Steak$7.49
Salad 4
- Wedge Salad$15.00
- MEXICAN SALAD (CACTUS)$17.49
- Taco Salad$15.94
- Cesar Salad$12.50
Starters 11
- Nachos$21.88
- Chips & Guacamole$18.44
- Costillas (Ribs) & Guacamole$22.19
- Shrimp Cocktail$23.44
- Quesabirria$25.94
- Ceviche$23.44
- HH Pambazo$10.00
- Tortilla Soup$16.56
- HH Tacos Steak$10.00
- HH Taquitos$10.00
- AY CARAMBA FRIES$21.88
Big Party 1
- BIG PARTY
Antojitos 2
- Huaraches$19.69
- Quesadilla$19.69
Kids Menu 4
- Chicken Strips$11.24
- Kids Burrito (Bean & Cheese)$11.24
- Kids Hamburger$11.24
- Kids Quesadilla$11.24
How these prices compare
Based on 595 menus with 44,447 priced items from Mexican restaurants in California, the median menu item costs $12.50, and half of all items are priced between $6.49 and $17.00.
At Ay Caramba! the median listed price is $12.50, close to the typical $12.50 for Mexican restaurants in California.
| Item | Here | Typical |
|---|---|---|
| Burrito | $19.69 | $12.00 |
| Chile Relleno | $23.44 | $9.72 |
| Nachos | $21.88 | $12.07 |
| Quesadilla | $19.69 | $11.46 |
Typical prices are calculated from 595 menus in our guide.
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated April 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.